Thursday, October 8, 2009

Ulmer Chapter 2

Part of what helped me unpack this chapter in Ulmer was the structure.
It essentially mirrors the organization of professional documents, more specifically, a proposal, and once I realized that, it became much easier to see what he was doing was.

He began with a prospectus summarizing the basic ideas of his Memorial, including its rationale, its relationship to the past, and the challenges in enacting it. He then goes on to put it into context, relating his commemoration of traffic accidents to a current event, the serial killer in Gainesville and the first Gulf War. The next section, the problem section, poses his question about putting private, individual crises in a broader framework so that their impact it realized, using support from Bataille. This use of past references is continued in the history section (comparable to a lit review) with the WWI soldier, Wittgenstein, and the Burma Shave sign.

The next section offers his qualifications to be the PI for this investigation: his experience with the architecture course, Heidegger, Dasein, Barthes, de-sign, de$ign.
This section is followed by the theory used, specifically Derrida and his mythos, logos, genos, chora, and coroner. All of this preceding material is essentially introductory, setting us up for his methodology, the use of the metaphor of the rhizome exemplified by weeds and the tumbleweed and the idea of sacrifice in primitive cultures. (I am reminded of Le Guin’s “Those Who Walked Away from Omelas” and Jackson’s “The Lottery.”)

We then get his proposal, the idea of showing the sacrifice of lives to highway fatalities in relation to lives lost in war, i. e. The Traffic Sphere, thereby making the former more perceptible. The rest of the proposal provides the details for creating this Memorial including the equipment needed, its cost-benefit, its goal, its similarity to the AID’s quilt, the references needed, and its significance. All of these are elements of a technical proposal, which is essentially what Ulmer is doing—proposing this project as a way to raise social consciousness about an everyday tragedy that we overlook.

Like most of you did the grammar for reading images, I also tried to relate Ulmer to electronic monuments. There are several involving the current Iraq War: http://www.iraqbodycount.org/

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2009/10/7/184216/526

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2009/9/24/785329/-IGTNTAll-in-their-twenties.

I also related his ideas to the tv series MASH and Ken Burns’s The War, most notably the use of an older war to provide commentary on a current one in an electronic medium. The Ken Burns film especially resonated with me because my small Midwest hometown was “commemorated” in it, and I have been able to see its impact.

No comments:

Post a Comment