Thursday, September 10, 2009

Kress and van Leeuwen Chapters 2 and 3

One aspect I like about the RCID Program is its interdisciplinary focus. It pulls me out of my comfort zone as these two chapters in Kress and van Leeuwen did. I don't think of myself as a visual person, having spent most of my career working with text, but I found them resonanting with me, especially my teaching and tutoring experiences. The past few months I've been tutoring a couple of MAPC students on their project paper/ thesis. Both of these young women
are working on visual projects, but each is having trouble writing up the research. It has me wondering if we as humans find one medium easier than the other.

One of the points I enjoyed in these chapters was the cultural influence on visuals. For the past couple of years I've been thinking about the remembrances we see by the side of the road in SC marking traffic accidents. Stuffed animals, flowers (both real and plastic), letters, pictures, ribbons in varying combinations commenorating loved ones--and the number of these monuments appears to be increasing. I contrasted these markers to ones I saw when I went home this past summer. South Dakota marks these spots with a diamond-shaped black and white sign with a large red X on it and the word THINK in thick black letters. These signs are far off the road in the fence line so as not to interfere with mowing in the summer. The difference between the two contrasts the practicality of Midwesterners with the more emotional Southerners.

When I took Visual Rhetorics a couple of years ago, we spent some time talking about if images could be "read." I'm ambivalent about this--at times I say, "sure we can read images," and then at times I think good heavens, no. So Kress and van Leeuwen's discussion of how the images exemplified grammatical and syntactical elements of text was helpful--and they had talked me into the fact that visuals and words are similar, if not the same (very comforting to me with my lack of confidence in understanding visuals). However, they then went on to show they were different. But this discussion helped; I now have a clearer idea of the two and what applies to both.

One of the most informative aspects of these two chapters was the discussion of the how the elements of graphic aids convey meaning. Even though I knew about double- and single-headed arrows, for example, I had never consciously thought about the meaning associated with the various ways the head and shaft could be joined or the meaning conveyed about the placement of elements in a picture or diagram. I was surprised, though, at how much of this information I used when I am teaching and tutoring. One thing I emphasize with students is that the type of visual used has to fit the purpose and the data. They can't use a pie chart, for example, unless they are showing parts of a whole (or 100%). It's surprising the number of students in technical fields who don't realize that line graphs have a specific informational function or that the lines and arrows between elements of a flow chart convey information about a process.

One of the best examples of this situation occurred this summer. I have been working with a Ph.D. student in computer science for a couple of years or more on her dissertation. She has developed a model for showing the thought process of students in solving problems. One of her committee members had questions about the role of short- and long-term memory. She and I struggled to work these answers into her document before I noticed her model did not match her discussion of it. She had placed memory across the top of the entire cognitative process, which was not a accurate representation. Since her research did not include memory, she removed it from the model--and that eliminated the questions, proving visual aids convey information--and they need to be an accurate representation. Kress and van Leeuwen have helped me understand the underlying concepts that support this, and I will use this information frequently.